Aria Stewart (aredridel) wrote,
Aria Stewart
aredridel

How I evaluate software

When I'm looking at software, I evaluate a lot of criteria. Usually, it's all in my head, since I'm good at keeping a feel for what others might use hard numbers for. Things I look at include:

  • Arrogance. Does the software try to invent a new organizational system, or does it just submit to the perfectly workable way that everyone else does it: libraries in /usr/lib, config files in /etc. Has it ignored installation issues entirely, and assumes it'll run out of the directory it's unpacked in? (This is a red flag for me: anything that demands special treatment like this is usually going to demand special attention every single time the system boots, every time it's installed on a new machine in the cluster, it'll need babysitting every step of the way. As a sysadmin who has plenty to attend to, this is not acceptable unless the software saves me a lot of time. That hasn't happened yet, either.)
  • Simplicity. Can I get an overview of how the code works in a few minutes? Some idea of what parts are magic, and what parts are easy? Is there magic everywhere, or just in a few performance critical spots? Boring is good. Really. If the way everyone else does stuff works, please don't reinvent the wheel. I grok the way everyone else does it already.
  • Modularity. If the interesting part of your application is pretty independent of the rest, do I have to install it all?
  • Orthagonality. Are unrelated parts tangled together? Can I use the pieces in ways you didn't intend? This is a good thing if so.
  • Standards compliance. That thing about arrogance? Yeah, that. Only more so.
Tags: geek
Subscribe

  • (no subject)

    You do occasionally visit Boston Public Library, yes? If not, get on it! You were raised in and on libraries. They are in your blood! You…

  • (no subject)

    "I had never been in a room of people who were going to say 'yes' to me before." My friend and I crammed into a rush hour crowded train…

  • Recipe: Storm in the Garden

    Recipe: Storm in the Garden Ingredients 10 ml lavender vodka 10 ml orange vodka 10 ml hibiscus vodka 200 ml ginger ale ice…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 2 comments